A number of particulars had been lacking from the Unsolved Mysteries investigation into the true story of the loss of life and unsolved thriller of Tiffany Valiante. The premiere episode of Unsolved Mysteries quantity 3, “Thriller at Mile Marker 45,” detailed how the favored scholar athlete disappeared from a celebration following an argument with a pal. As her household and pals had been trying to find her, Tiffany was hit by a practice roughly 4 miles from the place she was final seen. The investigators believed Tiffany died by suicide, however her dad and mom got here to be satisfied that she was murdered.

The Unsolved Mysteries‘ episode favors the Tiffany Valiantes’ dad and mom’ concept, largely as a result of the police officers who investigated the case declined to be interviewed for the episode. The Valiantes reject the concept that their daughter would ever die by suicide, noting that she was getting ready to go to school on a volleyball scholarship and a typically happy-go-lucky particular person. Whereas this does make the investigators’ theories relating to the occasions of that night time appear much less probably, the Netflix true crime present doesn’t focus on a number of indicators that Tiffany Valiante was considerably troubled. Conversely, the Unsolved Mysteries episode fails to say one key facet of the investigation that appears to verify the police’s findings, whereas additionally overlooking one among their most stunning oversights about Tiffany Valiante.

Associated: Unsolved Mysteries: Why The Alonzo Brooks Post-mortem Simply Redefined The Case

The Disappearing Ax

In response to Tiffany Valiante’s dad and mom and their advocate, Stephan M. Rosenfeld, the chief drawback with the investigation into Tiffany’s loss of life was that her case was overseen by the New Jersey Transit Police slightly than the native police division. Whereas Rosenfeld praised the Transit Police for his or her work, he famous that “their wheelhouse isn’t murder investigation and never suspicious loss of life investigation.” The Tiffany Unsolved Mysteries episode mentioned how the Transit Police didn’t safe the scene of Tiffany’s loss of life and missed key proof that would have confirmed that she was murdered. Nonetheless, the episode didn’t point out the element that the Transit Police investigators additionally misplaced a possible homicide weapon.

In response to a Tiffany Vialante replace from NJ.com in 2022, an ax that was coated with “pink markings” was discovered close to the positioning the place Tiffany Valiante’s physique was discovered. Tiffany’s household and pals hoped that forensic evaluation may show that the pink markings had been blood and that the blood may match Tiffany’s DNA. Sadly, the ax one way or the other went lacking whereas in storage earlier than it may very well be examined to see if it was related to any crime, a lot much less Tiffany Valiante’s loss of life particularly. This is without doubt one of the many issues with the Tiffany Valiante suicide concept.

Tiffany Valiante Stole Cash From Her Dad and mom

The Tiffany Unsolved Mysteries episode mentions that Tiffany Valiante had a combat with a pal on the night time of her loss of life and was accused of utilizing that pal’s bank card with out permission. Tiffany admitted that she was responsible of the theft to her mom shortly earlier than she disappeared. Whereas the episode paints Tiffany as a gifted scholar-athlete who ought to have recognized higher than to steal, this was not the primary time Tiffany Valiante had stolen from a liked one.

In response to civil deposition transcripts obtained by The Every day Beast, Tiffany Valiante had stolen cash from her dad and mom’ checking account just a few months earlier than her loss of life. Regardless of this, her mom defended Tiffany from her pal’s accusations of being a thief. Certainly, Unsolved Mysteries additionally does not present that the depositions reveal that Tiffany’s dad and mom had given her their bank card, nor that her mom particularly cited that as proof that Tiffany had no cause to steal from anybody.

Baby Protecting Providers Visited The Valiante Residence Repeatedly

One other element lacking from the Unsolved Mysteries Tiffany Valiante episode “Thriller at Mile Marker 45” is that the Valiantes had been suspected of abusing Tiffany Valiante earlier than her loss of life. In response to medical data obtained by The Every day Beast, Baby Protecting Providers (CPS) authorities visited the Valiante house on three separate events in 2014. This occurred after one among Tiffany’s lecturers seen bruising on her arm that appeared inconsistent with a sports-related harm. Although there’s mounting proof to help the Tiffany Valiante homicide concept, it is a little suspect.

Unsolved Mysteries doesn’t point out that Tiffany Valiante’s mom, Dianne Valiante, reportedly admitted to having punched Tiffany as soon as within the arm throughout an argument. The 2 each entered into remedy based mostly on the advice of their CPS caseworker. It must be famous, nevertheless, that the therapist was glad that Tiffany and Dianne had a “secure” relationship, regardless of having critical “hassle speaking” and Tiffany apparently lashing out at her dad and mom by stealing from them. It also needs to be famous that Tiffany Valiante particularly instructed her therapist that she was not “depressed nor suicidal.”

Associated: All the things Unsolved Mysteries Leaves Out About The Oslo Plaza Lady

A Okay-9 Unit Tracked Tiffany Valiante’s Erratic Journey

The Unsolved Mysteries‘ Tiffany Valiante episode goes into deep element choosing aside the New Jersey Transit Police concept relating to how Tiffany Valiante got here to die on the night time of July 12, 2015. As Unsolved Mysteries covers, it’s the authorities’ perception that Tiffany walked by the forest, stripped all the way down to her underwear, after which walked practically two miles barefoot, alongside the practice tracks, from the spot the place her sneakers and headband had been later discovered, to the positioning of her loss of life. Tiffany’s household discover this concept unlikely for a lot of causes, however the investigators did have one compelling piece of proof backing this chain of occasions, which went unreported by Unsolved Mysteries.

In response to the identical operations report initially obtained by The Every day Beast, a Okay-9 unit consisting of 1 bloodhound and one handler was despatched by the Atlantic County Sheriff’s Workplace to see if they may comply with Tiffany Valiante’s path and switch up any clues. The check was carried out on July 16, 2015, 4 days after Tiffany’s loss of life. The officer particularly requested to not be instructed the placement of the incident, so he might “conduct the monitor blind and let my Okay-9 associate cleared the path.” Unsolved Mysteries equally doesn’t point out the bloodhound’s hunt, which noticed the canine lead his handler alongside a 3.2-mile route that introduced him to the final space of Tiffany Valiante’s loss of life.

Whereas this seemingly disproves the Valiante household concept that Tiffany Valiante left her house in a motorcar, the Valiante household lawyer, Paul D’Amato, nonetheless questioned the reliability of the Okay-9 unit’s findings. The Every day Beast reported that, whereas touring the route with D’Amato, he famous that there had been heavy rains between the night time of Tiffany’s loss of life and the day the blind monitor was carried out, which ought to have made all of it however inconceivable for a bloodhound to trace any scents. Presumably, the Unsolved Mysteries Tiffany Valiante episode didn’t focus on this element on condition that many investigators think about Okay-9 models to be unreliable in monitoring lacking individuals, as police canine are typically educated to trace particular scents, corresponding to medication or bombs.

The Unsolved Mysteries Tiffany Valiante Household Has Re-Opened Curiosity In The Investigation

There have been many Tiffany Valiante updates since Unsolved Mysteries aired, and Tiffany Valiante’s household now reopened curiosity within the investigation of her loss of life. Following the Unsolved Mysteries Tiffany Valiante episode, Dianna Valiante is attempting to get the NJ Transit to take one other have a look at the case (by way of Press of Atlantic Metropolis), telling a board of administrators, “Greater than seven years after Tiffany’s loss of life, we’re extra satisfied than ever that investigators, together with members of your police division, had been mistaken, that they rushed to shut her case as a trespasser suicide, and we need to know why.”

The Unsolved Mysteries episode prompted a petition that urged the New Jersey Legal professional Basic’s Workplace to reexamine the case. Nonetheless, sadly, the case cannot be re-opened until new data is delivered to the Prosecutor’s Workplace. Nonetheless, Paul D’Amato, the legal professional representing the Valiantes, has been producing new leads following the Unsolved Mysteries episode. The Valiante household has even doubled the reward for details about Tiffany Valiante’s loss of life (by way of PR Newswire), which can result in a conviction and arrest of whoever is accountable.